This time is a Goodbye and not an Arrivederci.

The Island has always been insane. My parents brought me there first in 1992 and i have gone back basically every year since now with my family.
1. Scooters. In 1998 while driving to Colombier a kid flying down the road lost control and ended up on the hood of our Moke. Fortunately he was not hurt. So not much has changed un 28 years. After Irma scooter were truly out of control.
2. Fancy restaurants have always existed. Mayas during the High Season used to be the hot ticket.
3. Roads. I feel they are so much better than ever before. Also in 1998 before Abramovich redid the Goveneur road my parents were forced off of the road and blew a tire. Fortunately a nice resident up the road let them use their phone. I like the sidewalks and the speed bumps they have installed everywhere.
The island is far from perfect but it is pretty damn close. I have since travlled to Anguilla... insane beaches and the resorts are amazing but driving around the island is not scenic (trying to be nice). Turcs and Caicos, I was shocked at the state of the island outside of the resorts. But again beautiful beaches and amazing resorts.

We are heading back at the end of march into April and staying in Lurin. We will avoid Nikki Beach but we will sit on the beach with a bottle of super market Rose' on Sunday while my kids play in the water and we enjoy their music for free!
#3..I would add that the embedded road reflectors are super vision and safety aids when heading home at night.
 
Ha ha, Bob . . . a disconcerting fall in the Villa on Sunday, but no broken bones. “Gettin’ old ain’t for sissies,” as John Wayne famously said! Of course, despite bruises & some soft tissue damage, I’m successfully returning to my dining circuit! My favorite local restaurants have become caregivers . . . making sure that I’m well nourished!
Bonne récupération! Je suis tombée et fracturé ma hanche… ça fait quelques mois mais pénible! Courage!
 
This thread reminds me of the old Yogi Berra quote "Nobody goes there anymore, it's too crowded."

While I far prefer the "old St Barth" myself and would never step foot in the beach clubs of excess, I can't argue that they are ruining the island if more people are coming than ever before. Passing by St Jean is like playing Frogger with semi-drunk, semi-clad, semi-fashionistas.

The people ARE voting with their feet and we are losing the election.
 
"dreadful beach clubs"

a lot of this is just the vibe and scene that the younger generation wants
Cassidain fils and his petite amie are in Aspen skiing and sent a live photo yesterday from one of Veuve Clicquot's Sun Club popups, where they were doing a little après-ski. Sure enough, in the background is the loud thump-thump-thump of techno music to get everyone swaying and bobbing.
c'est la vie . . . and so forth
 
7p
This thread reminds me of the old Yogi Berra quote "Nobody goes there anymore, it's too crowded."

While I far prefer the "old St Barth" myself and would never step foot in the beach clubs of excess, I can't argue that they are ruining the island if more people are coming than ever before. Passing by St Jean is like playing Frogger with semi-drunk, semi-clad, semi-fashionistas.

The people ARE voting with their feet and we are losing the election.

I have to laugh! Playing Frogger is the exact description of driving past Nikki Beach! I was trying to think of what it reminds me of each time I go to Gustavia or just headed in that general direction. I feel like I am in a shooting gallery and taking my life in my hands. It would be nice if the parking was removed from the side of the road because I see more and more people who are unable to parallel park and who are completely clueless when backing into a spot. Then, of course, there are the humans that are dodging in and out like a drunk zombie apocalypse. Naturally, we have other ways around this dreaded area, but those are not ideal with the construction. Even though I am on “island time”, I still have work to do and calls that are scheduled so planning the death drive is a part of my day. Anyway, you did make me laugh! I may try to go play Frogger on the computer if it still exists!
 
We do not think we will go back to St Barth again. The island is becoming like a living city with all the infrastructure that a big city needs to have for its inhabitants to live but in a space which is too limited. The gigantic manicured villas are built everywhere, it is the main financial resource for the sant barthians to let them to the mega rich people of the world. I do not blame them it is the only financial resource they have. The roads are built and the traffic is colossal. The young generation move in scooters and that adds more chaos on the tiny but manicured roads. Everything is built to look pristine but nature and beauty of the island are slowly vanishing. So this time after twenty years was a real Goodbye and not an Arrivederci to Saint Barthélemy. I would not mention here the ugly and greedy behaviour of certain restaurants or dreadful beach clubs…
Totally get it...wrote extensively about a trip my 30yr old son took with his new finance to pop the ring in December...first came to the island on 1990...my son told me the over the top behavior by the new obnoxious rich...and restaurants was unprecedented and basically ruined their trip...only positive...which is most important...we have a future, awesome daughter in law...might have to leave my memories to just that...memories...
 
Totally get it...wrote extensively about a trip my 30yr old son took with his new finance to pop the ring in December...first came to the island on 1990...my son told me the over the top behavior by the new obnoxious rich...and restaurants was unprecedented and basically ruined their trip...only positive...which is most important...we have a future, awesome daughter in law...might have to leave my memories to just that...memories...

So sad an ending.
 
Totally get it...wrote extensively about a trip my 30yr old son took with his new finance to pop the ring in December...first came to the island on 1990...my son told me the over the top behavior by the new obnoxious rich...and restaurants was unprecedented and basically ruined their trip...only positive...which is most important...we have a future, awesome daughter in law...might have to leave my memories to just that...memories...
To be fair, weren't they here during the Christmas/New Year's holiday? That is probably not the best time to come here if you are not interested in obnoxious rich people and the restaurants clamoring to fleece them. Come in the summer when things are much more civilized.
 
Last edited:
I am surprised this thread is still going, kinda like the energizer bunny. it comes down to this, st. barths will never be like it was 30, 20, or even 10 years ago. no place is. the people are still the same if you take the time to speak to them. the beauty of the island, still here. the beaches are still beautiful. saline has not been developed, love an early morning walk there. colombier still great, getting there by a path or by boat.

I believe the real story here that is not mentioned is this, the people who no longer want to come here have gotten older, they no longer go to the beach unless its just outside a restaurant. they no longer hike as their own situation has changed with age. so what is left for them, I am not sure. everything changes, if it didn't we would stagnate.

I still like being able to go to the local hardware store and say put this on my tab. I pay them at the end of the month. does that still happen in the states?, no, not since the sixties or earlier. Its nice to know all my neighbors and others around the island, like a small town that really cares. I like that I can go to the doctor ( around 35 euros) or local pharmacist and I can tell him my health problems and he knows exactly the medicine that I need which is normally around 5 euros. I had a friend come over with her prescription which she pays 250 dollars a month for, it was less than 5 euros here to get it filled. so folks, it might not be the paradise for you. and if it isn't thats okay too.
 

Hello Didier​

I am surprised this thread is still going, kinda like the energizer bunny. it comes down to this, st. barths will never be like it was 30, 20, or even 10 years ago. no place is. the people are still the same if you take the time to speak to them. the beauty of the island, still here. the beaches are still beautiful. saline has not been developed, love an early morning walk there. colombier still great, getting there by a path or by boat.

I believe the real story here that is not mentioned is this, the people who no longer want to come here have gotten older, they no longer go to the beach unless its just outside a restaurant. they no longer hike as their own situation has changed with age. so what is left for them, I am not sure. everything changes, if it didn't we would stagnate.

I still like being able to go to the local hardware store and say put this on my tab. I pay them at the end of the month. does that still happen in the states?, no, not since the sixties or earlier. Its nice to know all my neighbors and others around the island, like a small town that really cares. I like that I can go to the doctor ( around 35 euros) or local pharmacist and I can tell him my health problems and he knows exactly the medicine that I need which is normally around 5 euros. I had a friend come over with her prescription which she pays 250 dollars a month for, it was less than 5 euros here to get it filled. so folks, it might not be the paradise for you. and if it isn't thats okay too.
Hello Didier,
You are spot on your assessment. Thank God I can still hike, climb stairs and enjoy the beauty of the Island fully as I did 20-years ago albeit a little slower. I can appreciate others that have aged and cannot do what they did 20-years ago or even 5-years ago. Yes, they probably quit coming. No reason to complain about it, life changes. I adore and LOVE St. Barth. I always feel very welcomed the minute I step foot off the plane; it is my HAPPY PLACE! Looking forward to my next upcoming trip with my #5 & #6 children. Already have our activities and dining plans in place. Countdown is on...

 
I think the aging out part is more about MedJets availability than activity. Many of us old folk still hike and stay very active, but fear being deprived of the comforts our nearby level 1 tramua hospital provides. YMMV
 
I think the aging out part is more about MedJets availability than activity. Many of us old folk still hike and stay very active, but fear being deprived of the comforts our nearby level 1 tramua hospital provides. YMMV
All the more reason to vacay at Terre Basses or La Samana rather than giving up on the FWI entirely.
 
I am surprised this thread is still going, kinda like the energizer bunny. it comes down to this, st. barths will never be like it was 30, 20, or even 10 years ago. no place is. the people are still the same if you take the time to speak to them. the beauty of the island, still here. the beaches are still beautiful. saline has not been developed, love an early morning walk there. colombier still great, getting there by a path or by boat.

I believe the real story here that is not mentioned is this, the people who no longer want to come here have gotten older, they no longer go to the beach unless its just outside a restaurant. they no longer hike as their own situation has changed with age. so what is left for them, I am not sure. everything changes, if it didn't we would stagnate.

I still like being able to go to the local hardware store and say put this on my tab. I pay them at the end of the month. does that still happen in the states?, no, not since the sixties or earlier. Its nice to know all my neighbors and others around the island, like a small town that really cares. I like that I can go to the doctor ( around 35 euros) or local pharmacist and I can tell him my health problems and he knows exactly the medicine that I need which is normally around 5 euros. I had a friend come over with her prescription which she pays 250 dollars a month for, it was less than 5 euros here to get it filled. so folks, it might not be the paradise for you. and if it isn't thats okay too.

Hello Didier​


Hello Didier,
You are spot on your assessment. Thank God I can still hike, climb stairs and enjoy the beauty of the Island fully as I did 20-years ago albeit a little slower. I can appreciate others that have aged and cannot do what they did 20-years ago or even 5-years ago. Yes, they probably quit coming. No reason to complain about it, life changes. I adore and LOVE St. Barth. I always feel very welcomed the minute I step foot off the plane; it is my HAPPY PLACE! Looking forward to my next upcoming trip with my #5 & #6 children. Already have our activities and dining plans in place. Countdown is on...

Great exchange! It also has been interesting to me to see how the topic “has legs.” It clearly comes down to two groups expressing different viewpoints as they arise, I believe, from (a) real acquaintance with the island vs. (b) an overly-simplistic view (without wanting to insult anyone in the latter camp, it might be described as a cosmetic view).

Diana unquestionably speaks as a “local.” Seeing, knowing, & experiencing island glamour . . . while simultaneously embedded in its heritage & values. Intimately tied into island culture . . . connected to it through relationships which are related, socially & in so many other ways, in centuries of tradition, style, & respect for others & the rock that is home.

There are others, such as dadto6, who achieve, by frequency of visits to — & time spent on — the island, a semblance of what Diana knows & describes. An important factor here is a nuance that is rarely achieved by occasional visitors — that is, true personal connections with “locals,” like one has with friends “back home.” Such relationships are difficult to achieve in any community & generally are found only over time and meeting the same people, over & over, in places like the hardware & grocery stores & at Church.

Regular, respectful, recurring — even if only annual — visits to the same restaurants, boulangeries, shops, beaches, & bars go a distance in building local ties. The common goal of diversion in spending time on SBH, however, void of ”real world“ matters, has been crushed for many by disdain of manicured villas, navigating colossal traffic, growing expense related to enjoying the fantasy world of SBH, etc. “Becoming like a living city,” as hydraaa wrote.

As friend Amy has often reminded us, ”Yesterday’s the past, tomorrow’s the future, but today is a gift. That’s why it’s called the present.”
 
I think the aging out part is more about MedJets availability than activity. Many of us old folk still hike and stay very active, but fear being deprived of the comforts our nearby level 1 tramua hospital provides. YMMV
Understood, it is all about personal choices. My point is to discourage the bashing of the island because you choose not to come any longer. As Dennis has written, I have created many friendships with locals and enjoy every moment that I spend of the Island. Those are my feelings and my choice, I have traveled extensively and St. Barth checks my boxes. However, I enjoy our oceanfront villa at OBX each Labor Day, which makes it easier for our entire family to join with their busy schedules.
 
Last edited:
Top