Page 2 of 3 FirstFirst 1 2 3 LastLast
Results 31 to 60 of 74
  1. #31
    mkunst is offline
    SBH Member Joined: Mar 2015 Posts: 116

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    I only told the ant story because I thought it was funny. I don't even consider that incident to be significant in my opinion of the place. It was just everything was poorly executed from the moment we walked in the door at 9 until we left at 11:35. And, to top it off, when I said to the expediter in a joking manner that they seemed to be having some minor problems that evening she looked like the top of her head was going to explode and said something along the lines of "oh no, monsieur, you have to expect this on NYE." I said no more--until the ants, anyway.

  2. #32
    andynap is offline
    SBH Insider Joined: Oct 2002 Philadelphia Posts: 41,756

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    Having ants in a bread basket can happen. Sending the same bread back- I assuming- toasted is something else.
    If you're going through hell, keep going- Winston Churchill

    Andy

  3. #33
    mkunst is offline
    SBH Member Joined: Mar 2015 Posts: 116

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    Quote Originally Posted by andynap View Post
    Having ants in a bread basket can happen. Sending the same bread back- I assuming- toasted is something else.
    true.

  4. #34
    Mike R is offline
    SBH Insider Joined: May 2003 Stinson Lake - New Hampshire & Provincetown - Cape Cod Posts: 51,990

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    I would think it's pretty challenging for most restaurants to put their best foot forward on NYE.....some do it better than others but it certainly has its challenges
    "When the power of love overcomes the love of power the world will know peace" Jimi Hendrix

  5. #35
    mkunst is offline
    SBH Member Joined: Mar 2015 Posts: 116

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    Quote Originally Posted by Mike R View Post
    I would think it's pretty challenging for most restaurants to put their best foot forward on NYE.....some do it better than others but it certainly has its challenges

    Worked plenty of NYEs in my time in the biz during an extended undergrad and prior to a grad school--from pizza joints to the one of the best restaurants on the East Coast (at the time). While not as bad as Valentine's day in this country, NYE is something of an amateur night for patrons. That being said, Eddy's was, and I'll go back to my original characterization, amateurish.

  6. #36
    Mike R is offline
    SBH Insider Joined: May 2003 Stinson Lake - New Hampshire & Provincetown - Cape Cod Posts: 51,990

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    Yeah I hear ya ...well we live and work in a resort and for us on NYE we go to the local Pub early in the evening and then we hunker down at home for the night ....
    "When the power of love overcomes the love of power the world will know peace" Jimi Hendrix

  7. #37
    JEK is offline
    Senior Insider Joined: Jan 2004 In the ether . . . Posts: 51,696

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    Really surprising that Eddy and Brigette would be that far out of control. I've dined with them for years, including a couple of big birthday bashes for Marius that were like NYE and Christmas Eve rolled into one. I'm guessing they were slammed all week from Christmas on and the last big bash put them over the top.
    The Marius 100th Birthday Party -- June 5, 2023

  8. #38
    mkunst is offline
    SBH Member Joined: Mar 2015 Posts: 116

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    Quote Originally Posted by Mike R View Post
    Yeah I hear ya ...well we live and work in a resort and for us on NYE we go to the local Pub early in the evening and then we hunker down at home for the night ....
    Yep. Usually, a couple of early cocktails out at the local bar and then dinner, wine and champagne at home with friends for us.

  9. #39
    mkunst is offline
    SBH Member Joined: Mar 2015 Posts: 116

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    Quote Originally Posted by JEK View Post
    Really surprising that Eddy and Brigette would be that far out of control. I've dined with them for years, including a couple of big birthday bashes for Marius that were like NYE and Christmas Eve rolled into one. I'm guessing they were slammed all week from Christmas on and the last big bash put them over the top.
    This is the last time (I promise) and I know at this point I am beating a dead horse--but it is was really shockingly bad (and i didn't even have a bad table, which can really pis* me off). But, hey, it was sold out!

  10. #40
    JEK is offline
    Senior Insider Joined: Jan 2004 In the ether . . . Posts: 51,696

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    I'll be there March the 4th (always our 1st night stop) and give a full report
    The Marius 100th Birthday Party -- June 5, 2023

  11. #41
    KevinS is offline
    Senior Insider Joined: Jul 2003 Boston Posts: 17,429

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    Quote Originally Posted by JEK View Post
    Really surprising that Eddy and Brigette would be that far out of control.
    Isn't Mahé mostly running the show these days?

  12. #42
    JEK is offline
    Senior Insider Joined: Jan 2004 In the ether . . . Posts: 51,696

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    He is the wine buyer, but all three have been there every time I've eaten there.
    The Marius 100th Birthday Party -- June 5, 2023

  13. #43
    cec1 is offline
    SBH Insider Joined: Jul 2008 Posts: 3,534

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    Quote Originally Posted by KevinS View Post
    Isn't Mahé mostly running the show these days?
    . . . not when Eddy &/or Brigette is/are there (especially the latter!). In addition, the long time chef pretty much "runs" the kitchen (great deference given to the chef by all of them, with Eddy clearly having influence . . . which he rarely chooses to exercise).

  14. #44
    tim is offline
    Moderator Joined: Jun 2003 Vélo, Virginia Posts: 16,555

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    Quote Originally Posted by mkunst View Post
    This is the last time (I promise) and I know at this point I am beating a dead horse--but it is was really shockingly bad (and i didn't even have a bad table, which can really pis* me off). But, hey, it was sold out!
    mkunst,

    I'm sorry to hear about your experience at Eddy's, one of my long time favorites.
    The best moderation is the least moderation.

  15. #45
    tomb1954 is offline
    SBH Member Joined: Mar 2011 Smithfield, VA Posts: 99

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    Admittedly we're a bit out of touch with the current scene! That said, Le Repaire was always solid for lunch, and La Plage, though somewhat uneven, was a truly fun place for a 4-top or more of friends and acquaintances! Especially when a fashion show blossomed...
    Hobbes : "Do you think there's a God?
    Calvin : "Well somebody's out to get me!"

  16. #46
    thomasj is offline
    SBH Member Joined: Nov 2009 Toronto Posts: 115

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    hey hey,
    thanks for the thread! Very interesting reading about everyone's experiences at all the variety of restaurants on the island. I've been visiting SBH since only 2009 (10,13,15,16 - the island is addictive ) and seen a fair amout of turnover but also a good amount of spots that are holding on strong thru the years. Restaurants are a touch and go proposition in NYC/Toronto cannot imagine running one on an island with no resources.
    Back to the thread - In my personal experiences, I have found that the cost of a menu has absolutely no impact on the service or food quality. I've had some terrible food at expensive places and good food at "cheap" spots. Some of my biggest standouts:
    - Grain de Sel: visit everytime for lunch, due to location to my favourite beach. Food is always prepared well and solid value, however sadly the service really ranges (really good to really, really bad - never terrible), and a lunch can be a 2 hour affair, but I always go.
    - Maya's (polarizing place I know) its pretty solid, the food is not fancy, simple really and way overpriced but I personally have had good service here and the crowd is nice.
    - Nikki Beach (a chain, but a chic one) I find the food and service much better than you would expect at such a place. A lunch here is lots of fun, not the case in many other spots.
    - Le Tamarin (another polarizing spot) - again in my experiences here very solid. The menu certainly is not the most exciting one on the island however the service level is very high here.
    - Isoleta, I like the pizza here, the casual yet chic feel and again I've had very good service here.
    - The Hideaway (well liked on this board), tried this spot 3 different visits (with friends) and sorry but I find the food sucks and the staff here is about the rudest on the island that I've experienced.
    - L'Entracte - another solid "value" pick and good service. Sad that the pizzas are not being done there anymore though.
    - Le Select - love love this place but for the vibe, people and strong drinks only, I find the burgers here vile.

    This trip I am set to try out (for the 1st time): Bonito and Orega. I have high expectations and will report back!
    cheers, T
    LAST VISIT: January 2017
    St. Barth Je t'aime (except all the smoking...)

  17. #47
    thomasj is offline
    SBH Member Joined: Nov 2009 Toronto Posts: 115

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    Quote Originally Posted by GramChop View Post
    Black Ginger.
    hello there!
    just curious - have you eaten in the restaurant? I have taken out food from their adjacent food counter and found the food quite poor quality (especially for the price) maybe the sit down is better? merci!
    LAST VISIT: January 2017
    St. Barth Je t'aime (except all the smoking...)

  18. #48
    cec1 is offline
    SBH Insider Joined: Jul 2008 Posts: 3,534

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    Interesting feedback, thomasj . . . thanks for your thoughts. A couple of questions / comments: (a) Re: Hideaway, are you speaking of experience before Andy left the restaurant (about two years ago) . . . or since operations were taken over by Hafida? (b) Please let me know what you think of L'Isoleta after you try it on your upcoming trip . . . prices have gone up, in my opinion, rather significantly. Food's still great, but no longer a relative bargain. (c) Have you tried La Gloriette? and (d) if you haven't tried it, go to Le Repaire . . . not high profile or glamorous, but very nice staff & generally very good food, relative to price. (I particularly like going there for breakfast.)

  19. #49
    GramChop is offline
    SBH Insider Joined: Jul 2007 Austin, Texas Posts: 16,203

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    Quote Originally Posted by thomasj View Post
    hello there!
    just curious - have you eaten in the restaurant? I have taken out food from their adjacent food counter and found the food quite poor quality (especially for the price) maybe the sit down is better? merci!
    Hey, Thomas! I have ONLY eaten in the restaurant (5 times) and the one negative I can say is: Last summer I dined with two friends and we each ordered something different so we could pass our dishes around the table giving us each the opportunity to taste three separate items. One friend ordered that what I would normally order so I chose to order something unique. I did and while it wasn't awful, it was too spicy and cream-heavy for my taste. The service is always exceptional and I find the value to quality ratio exceptional. Now, with that being said, I mean, how expensive can Pad Thai be? And, a couple of glasses of wine added to the bill still allows me to call the experience budget-friendly.

    I'm sorry your experience wasn't up to par and do hope you'll give Black Ginger another chance. The interior of the restaurant ALONE is worth a sit down. All this in my opinion, of course.
    The waves of the sea bring me back to me.

  20. #50
    Bart -my real name- is offline
    SBH Insider Joined: Nov 2009 Alexandria, VA Posts: 4,834

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    Re: Hideaway - Lately we've been spending our first two nights in St. Jean, and the Hideaway has been our traditional first-night meal. The food we had in December was good, but I think it was a step or two down from what it was when Andy was there. We liked the pizza best out of everything we ordered. The service on the other hand was great. Our server was an impossibly bubbly and high energy young woman who just arrived from France a couple weeks prior (probably mid to late November). She was an absolute blast, and the complete opposite of rude. Hafida (who we don't know other than eating there once a year) came over to our table and greeted us with hugs and kisses like we were Phil and Amy!

  21. #51
    scotth is offline
    SBH Member Joined: Sep 2010 Posts: 42

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    "Hafida (who we don't know other than eating there once a year) came over to our table and greeted us with hugs and kisses like we were Phil and Amy!"

    The pizza and greeting from Hafida the first night on the island is worth the visit for us. Last trip we returned a second night just for that very reason.

  22. #52
    mgk5u is offline
    SBH Member Joined: Jan 2010 Posts: 21

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    Just an update-- our best meals included dinner at Santa Fe (gnocchi with truffles), dinner at Esprit (the most attentive wine service ever!), lunch at Cabana de Isle (truffle pasta, grilled lobster), and dinner at Orega (everything was outstanding). On the Rocks had memorable moments but the entire dinner felt rushed-- and expensive! Black Ginger was very good-- but also a very quick meal-- I think they needed our table for a later reservation. I was also disappointed in Tamarin-- it had always been one of my favorites, but lunch was a very small menu and the meal was just ok. The re-design was beautiful, though! On the flip side, La Plage for lunch took almost 3 hours. The lobster was good, but not as good as Santa Fe. Pics coming soon.

    Wonderful trip, crazy weather (a boat washed up on St Jean and caused Nikki Beach to close for 2 days!), but so so good to be back!!!

  23. #53
    cassidain is offline
    SBH Insider Joined: Jul 2007 Ailleurs Posts: 5,648

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    this boat?

    Name:  15966164_10155021036329301_115979330514666449_n.jpg
Views: 227
Size:  61.5 KB
    HB's FB
    Fils du Sud - Ministre de la Santé

    If I can't wear my Havaianas, I ain't goin'...ÀMHA

  24. #54
    KevinS is offline
    Senior Insider Joined: Jul 2003 Boston Posts: 17,429

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    It wasn't just the boat. The high surf, lack of beach, and restaurant full of sand had an impact too.

  25. #55
    andynap is offline
    SBH Insider Joined: Oct 2002 Philadelphia Posts: 41,756

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    Quote Originally Posted by KevinS View Post
    It wasn't just the boat. The high surf, lack of beach, and restaurant full of sand had an impact too.
    Name:  FullSizeRender.jpg
Views: 274
Size:  352.4 KB
    If you're going through hell, keep going- Winston Churchill

    Andy

  26. #56
    ccg is offline
    SBH Insider Joined: Dec 2009 Durham, NC Posts: 608

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    Agree with mgk5u, that the gnocchi with truffles at Santa Fe is delicious. I think that was my favorite dish of our vacation. I would absolutely order this again. I even asked for more bread so I didn't leave any sauce behind.

    What happened to the beach at Nikki's? Is there missing beach by La Plage?

    C
    "There are no foreign lands. It is the traveller only who is foreign" Robert Louis Stevenson
    House Divided - Roll Tide War Eagle

  27. #57
    amyb is online now
    SBH Insider Joined: Apr 2008 Glen Cove,L. I., NY Posts: 22,224

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    La Plage was ok yesterday at lunch time.
    Remember Yesterday, Dream About Tomorrow, But Live Today.

  28. #58
    elgreaux is online now
    SBH Insider Joined: May 2003 Saint Barth Posts: 9,181

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    Nikki Beach was open today, Sunday...

  29. #59
    cassidain is offline
    SBH Insider Joined: Jul 2007 Ailleurs Posts: 5,648

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    effects on la plage at flamands of same agitated seas

    Name:  16105539_1885152771720852_5955597002027558460_n.jpg
Views: 150
Size:  104.7 KB
    Fils du Sud - Ministre de la Santé

    If I can't wear my Havaianas, I ain't goin'...ÀMHA

  30. #60
    amyb is online now
    SBH Insider Joined: Apr 2008 Glen Cove,L. I., NY Posts: 22,224

    Re: Favorite restaurants?

    Two weeks. I am surprised more houses didn't get built.
    Remember Yesterday, Dream About Tomorrow, But Live Today.

Similar Threads