We've been burned a few times at Menton so I have pretty much taken all Barbara Lynch restaurants out of the rotation and the last time we tried to eat at the bat at No. 9 we ended up ordering sushi to go that we picked up on the way home because the wait was so long at the bar (of course right after I called for sushi two seats opened up). We may have to give that another try because it has been a long time and I like the room.
I wrote up our Select lunch with pics if you are interested -
http://www.pearlsandoysters.com/2015/12/13/boston-select-oyster-bar/ - Ironically (I thought) the "hooch" of the day was a Ti Punch. I really do think it is a great place.
Any favs in Cambridge/Somerville?
Do give the bar at No. 9 Park another try. My recent experiences there have been very positive and I love that I can order from the bar or regular menus.
We've enjoyed many good dinners in Boston/Cambridge, but only a few really great ones so far. We have not tried Menton yet and may not after your review. We were disappointed with Sportello and that was after a strong recommendation from the chef at Amis in Philly. I have yet to find an Italian restaurant in Boston that I love as much as any of Marc Vetri's restaurants in Philly. I am hoping that will change if I can score a reservation at Giulia's. We ate at Crudo in the North End on Saturday and I would not go back. We've been to Babbo in the Seaport and it was surprisingly excellent.
We've dined at Alden & Harlow in Harvard Square a few times. We found the burger to be over-hyped...good, not great. They just landed the no. 1 spot on Boston Magazine's top 50 list. The food is locally sourced, creative and very good. For carnivores, Craigie on Main has a much better burger.
My favorites in Cambridge are Oleana, West Bridge, Cafe Sushi, Russell House Tavern and Sofra Bakery. I especially enjoy Oleana. I've tried to get a spot in cooking classes with Ana Sortun, but they fill quickly. Russell House Tavern has a really great burger and I love the melted leek and white truffle oil pizza. Dennis really enjoys the omakase at Cafe Sushi and he thinks it rivals the sushi at Oishii and O Ya. For $80, the omakase is a steal. Unfortunately, West Bridge just announced they are closing at the end of this month.
Last month we were in the Fenway neighborhood and ended up at Sweet Cheeks. I am not a big BBQ person, but I thought the food was delicious.
If you like Island Creek oysters (the oyster, not the restaurant), they typically have them at the inside and outside bars at The Red House in Harvard Square for 50 cents each before 6:00 p.m. and $1 each after 6:00. I don't love Red House's menu, but it's a great place to stop for a dozen oysters and a glass of wine for $20.
Your photos form Select Oyster Bar are fantastic. I was compelled to go online and book a table. (Thank you.) They were wide open for Tuesday and Wednesday.