Petri,
I totally agree with your last line...and hope you can get out and explore all that you can, for sure!!!!!
The reason we are going back to Anguilla next month, is like you sai, "good old list" (that and a change, since I did spend 3 weeks in St Barths in Nov.
But, as far as restos, I would compare Eddy's to Oliver's on Anguilla....and Straw Hat or barrel Stay (check out their menu website) to Wall House.
I agree with what you said about Temenos and Viceroy; but we will split our time, and stay at Cusinart for 3 nights. When they first built it, we went for drinks, I have never met such friendly, helpful people that work there. Now, I may have to agree aboput some of the clientele.....but if you hang with the natives, it's all cool.
I look forward to a newbie report, and also yours, from Spain !!!!!! Our new exploring this year will be Sicliy......and perhaps Chile this time if our son goes back again!!!!!!