I appreciate all of the input. I just wish that message boards had existed when I first started going.
“safety and little crime” – I think that Andy hit on a key benefit.
I’m not an expert on SBH, but I do know one thing beyond a shadow of a doubt. It was my first true love for a vacation destination and to this day it is the only place that I’ve truly loved. I’ve liked many places, but none of the other places have instilled pure love.
I’m going to attempt to answer my own question in concrete terms. In my opinion SBH is unique in our hemisphere. The features that set it apart from any other island or vacation destination are: small, French, hilly and safe.
The ramifications from each of these are many. Being small it is easy to create a “home” familiarity with the places and people we get to know. From the airport to the grocery to the beaches, restaurants, harbor, etc it is easy to become familiar with one’s surroundings.
Being French provides a level of casual chic as well as great food and accommodations. I think it also provides an air of sophistication that is lacking in other destinations. There are other French islands, but they are all much larger and less intimate feeling.
Being hilly not only gives great vistas but also is a key reason that this was not a good location for colonial farming. The offshoot of this is the island culture has a strong Euro influence. We also know this is not a “poor” island as so many Carib islands are.
Being safe adds greatly to the sense of relaxation. You can walk, drive and park anywhere and feel safe – at least in my experience.
Wrap all of these things together and I don’t think any other island in the Carib can compare head to head with SBH. I discovered ti-punch there which is now my favorite drink - period. The creperie in town is my favorite eatery in the Carib simply because I love creperies. In the years since I first discovered SBH, there have been countless occasions when I could bring up my feelings while camped out on a beach and bring back the sense of relaxation. I know that the most relaxed days of my life were spent on this island.