Restaurant report 18-31 January 2015

slesgold

SBH Insider
Just got home from 2 wonderful weeks at Villa Manon/Henson and already decided to return next year. Yay! Anyway, thought I'd submit this brief summary of our dining. Except when noted all food was good-to-very good and meal was dinner. I've chosen to call Mahi-Mahi daurade for no particular reason, but thought I'd mention it. "Red snapper" is Vivaneau (Rose or Rouge or Oeil de Boeuf). All "Accras" are of the cod (morue) variety. We mostly returned to places we'd been before, but also visited a few classics that somehow we'd never been to.

Gustav Burger - lunch - We had burgers and they were good. Best we had on the island.

La Langouste - We had Accras, red snapper, lobster bisque, and pork cheeks - This is one of our favorite SBH restaurants. Service is superb (Benjamin is probably the best server on the island) and food is very dependably excellent.


Hideaway - We had pizza and steak. Service is excellent and the pizza seems so much better than it seemed in prior years. Now rivals excellent Wisconsin thin-crust pizza. Hafida is so much more charming than Andy! :tongue:


Provença - We had the tomato tarte (nothing like the one at Santa Fe, but every bit as good if not better) , Med. Sea Bass, duck, and the zuzu lemon tarte. Food and service were excellent. Decor is beautiful with the changes (and I liked it before as Wall House!). Will return.


Grain de Sel - We had Crab croustillant, red snapper, ouassous (river prawns, which I thought would be crayfish, but are more like a rock lobster), and coconut creole pie. The food was good, but the service was not. I don't think it was the fault of the servers, rather that they have about half the staff they need for the number of tables, especially in comparison to nearly every other restaurant on the island. We will likely not return as it wasn't good enough for the price or drive.


Le Select - lunch - We had burgers (Surprise!). Interestingly, this was our first visit. I liked the burger in a Wendy's sort of way. My wife was less enamored. Breeze was great and I liked my experience. Much to my surprise, it was not the least bit busy, but that seemed to be true everywhere during our 2 weeks.

Les Bananiers - We ate here twice and had Accras, moules frites, daurade steak, and veggie pizza. We loved it here and will make this a regular stop for us. The moules frites were the best I've ever had (it is a special about once a month on a Saturday). The pizza was good, but not even close to that of The Hideaway.



Gloriette - lunch - We had salade exotique and daurade. This is another of our favorite places and it didn't disappoint.

Marche Bio (Le boucherie St. Jean) - OK, not exactly a restaurant, but we got takeout from the BBQ on a Sunday and ate it for dinner. Open during the lunch hour; not sure of the exact hours, but about 11-2. We had ribs and chicken as well as corn on the cob. Ribs were very good. Chicken not so much. Corn was nearly inedible. We'll definitely return for the ribs next year, but we'll get enough for leftovers and get other items from elsewhere, e.g., Maya's to Go, to accompany the ribs.



L'Esprit - We had Crab salad, Dover sole, black pork, and cherry cake. In my opinion, this is easily the best restaurant on the island. Everything was outstanding. The thought put into melding flavors in something like the crab salad was incredible.


Le Carre - lunch - We had steak tartare, special salad w/cottage cheese and pancetta tartine, and a lobster roll. Excellent place for lunch. Also on the favorites list.

Le Repaire - We had Accras, a daurade special, cheeseburger w/frites, chocolate sundae, and fruit. Another classic that we'd somehow never been to. Enjoyed it thoroughly.



Meat & Potatoes - We had salad, spinach potato soup, rib of beef for two w/mashed carrots, gratin dauphinois and béarnaise, Roquefort, porcini and another sauce. It was very good. We'd never been before. Service was outstanding.


Le Creperie - breakfast - We had an omelette and a galette with ham, Swiss and egg. Galette was excellent! Great spot for breakfast.

Santa Fe - We had tomato tart, coq au vin, and peach melba. Excellent meal and service.


Maya's - We had beignets crevettes, daurade, red snapper with green curry, and chocolate cake. Amazingly, our first visit. Food was excellent and service was very good. We may or may not go back as the prices were ridiculous when compared to what you get. Unlike L'Esprit, you notice the price not quite fitting what you get; at L'Esprit, everything seems completely in line with what you pay.


Wonderful 2 weeks on the best island in the Western Hemisphere!
 
Thanks! It's always nice to see the restaurants through someone else's eyes (and tastes).
 
Steve, excellent, detailed reporting. Thanks for taking the time to share your dining experiences.
 
Great report, Steve! Many of our favorite restaurants, as well.

As a fellow Wisconsin-ite, we've been debating going to Meat and Potatoes because it's hard to beat Midwestern beef and we almost always are disappointed in the quality of the beef when we travel. How did it compare, in your opinion?
 
Great report, Steve! Many of our favorite restaurants, as well.

As a fellow Wisconsin-ite, we've been debating going to Meat and Potatoes because it's hard to beat Midwestern beef and we almost always are disappointed in the quality of the beef when we travel. How did it compare, in your opinion?


That's a very good question. it was the exact reason I passed on going there the last time I was on the island. I would say that it's very good. Not as good as Tornado or Capitol Chophouse in Madison or Butch's in Milwaukee or the good chains like Morton's, Ruth's Chris, The Palm, etc., but better than any other place I've had beef in the Caribbean. Sides were very good, especially the mashed carrots (I think I was in a high chair the last time I had mashed carrots; these are far superior to Gerber's) Meat was done to our liking (medium rare). Also, it's not goofy expensive, just St. Barth-expensive. Sides were good too. If you're getting tired of Langouste, Daurade and Vivanneau, it's worth trying. If you're looking for a one special place and you're trying to decide between L'Esprit or Provença, pick one of those.
 
I would say that it's very good. Not as good as Tornado or Capitol Chophouse in Madison or Butch's in Milwaukee or the good chains like Morton's, Ruth's Chris, The Palm, etc., but better than any other place I've had beef in the Caribbean.

Careful, you're approaching Mike R territory here. :devilish:
 
Oh Bart! You must elaborate! You can't leave me hanging like that!
If you are a regular reader of these forums there are several posters who criticize certain restaurants as to food, size of portions, frozen fish, prices, etc. Mike is one, I am too as are several others.
 
If you are a regular reader of these forums there are several posters who criticize certain restaurants as to food, size of portions, frozen fish, prices, etc. Mike is one, I am too as are several others.

I'd say that this is a callout to Mike R to comment on what I said. Very curious. Does he like or dislike M&P?
 
I thought it was obvious


Slesgold and MantyPam were talking about the high quality of Midwestern beef and the stuff on SBH (possibly) not measuring up to the stuff they get at home. That reminded me of about 40,000 of Mike's posts! :devilish:

"The seafood sucks compared to mine"
"The veggies suck compared to mine"
"The boat mooring sucks compared to mine"
"We eat (at the villa) better than you do (at a restaurant)"
"We hang out at better beaches than you do"


For the record, I like Mike's posts and have learned a lot from them, it's just when I read about "Midwestern beef", Mike was first thing that popped into my head.


Peace, love and understanding
 
Top