Pirate,
We prefer Guanahani with its poolside dining and the views of the Grande Fond. We don't know about this year but each time we have gone in the past, it has always been a little 'off.' Maybe because of the great big restaurant and few people dining there. It just doesn't have the atmosphere of Eden Roc, IDF, Taiwana, Guanahani, and Gaiac, which are always bustling with diners, fashion shows, and other events.